Listening to the Cries of the Earth and the Cries of the Poor (Climate Change Sunday)

The scriptures, both the Jewish and the Christian, present God’s concern for the poor (anawim). God has always been partial to the poor, the vulnerable, and the oppressed. To practice care for the poor means that we identify with the poor, listen to their struggles to survive and the tragedies that they experience. In the segment “Crimes Against Nature” from the video series, Renewal, we witness how mountain tops are wastefully harvested through explosions, toxic chemicals polluting the water table and streams harming humans and other life. I am deeply touched by the testimony of the mother who bathes her child in water laced with arsenic and other toxins. We hear the cries of the land as the coal companies explode the mountain tops and the cries of animal and human life. Here the poor are the cries of the Earth community and all life, human and non-human. They are the poor, and they will be the ones to most suffer the climate changes of the future. The poor always suffer while the wealthy have means to escape the ravages. God’s option for the poor includes the Earth and all life that inhabits the Earth. Albert Schweitzer remarked, “Ethics means unlimited responsibility for everything existing and alive.”

I want to address how we as Earth-centered Christians might approach the scripture and try to listen to voices of the Earth in the Bible and how Jesus gives an example how we relate to the cries of the Earth and the poor.

The prophet Hosea utters these words some 2600 years ago, but they could today over what humans are doing to the land.

Hear the words of the Lord, O people of Israel, for the Lord has a case against the inhabitants of the land. There is no faithfulness and loyalty, and no knowledge of God in the land. Swearing, lying, murder and stealing and adultery break out; bloodshed follows bloodshed. Therefore the land mourns, and who live in it languish, together with the wild animals and the birds of the air, even the fish of the sea. (Hosea 4:1-3)

This reading could be easily applied to human recklessness in mountain top harvesting of coal, destroying the environment, harming animal life and human beings alike for greed of energy. Here in Hosea we hear the land, the Earth voicing its indictment against humanity.

Humans are created in God’s image so they can exercise dominion of the earth. They ordered to subdue and dominate the Earth in Genesis 1. And this has become a human principle in dominating the Earth, exploiting greedily its resources, without any constraint or thought of future generations. Sallie McFague has three principles for human beings living with the Earth: Take your share (of resources), Clean up after yourself, and Keep the house (Earth) in repair for future occupants. These are good principles to remember as we live out vocation as “Green” or Earth-centered Christians.

First, Hosea states, ‘there is no faithfulness and loyalty, and no knowledge of God in the land.” Because of the command to subdue and dominate in the account of Genesis, humanity has often attempted to dominate, exploit recklessly, and without any thought than short term profitability and greed. But what about life impacted? What about the future for later generations? Hosea’s indictment that “no knowledge of God in the land” points to the secular devaluation of the Earth and other life to serve its own purpose. It has forgotten the wisdom that our ancestors and native people have long known…
We have lost our ability to listen to the voices of the land, the plants and trees, and animals and the voices of the sea. We ignore the agonized cries of all those from the Earth-community. There is a profound selfishness that ignores the poor and homeless and blame them for their plight.

We listen to the voice of the Earth here and other places in scripture. There are six “green” or creation-centered principles that we need to be aware of when we read the Bible according to biblical scholar Norman Habel who has shepherded the Earth Bible Project:

1) The universe, the Earth and all its components have intrinsic worth. All creation is loved by God.
2) The Earth is a community of interconnected living things that are mutually dependent on each other for life and survival.
3) The Earth is a subject capable of raising its voice in celebration and against injustice.
4) The universe, Earth and its components are a part of dynamic cosmic design within which each piece has a place to play in the overall goal of that design.
5) Earth is a balanced and divine domain where responsible custodians can function as partners with, rather than rulers over Earth, to sustain its balance and a diverse Earth community.
6) Earth and its components not only suffer from human injustice but actively resist them in the struggle for justice. Introducing Ecological Hermeneutics

These Earth-centered principles are used by Jewish and Christian interpreters of the Bible. Such readings shift a human-centric reading of scripture and provides a more inclusive creation-centered perspective, that is, a perspective from God.
I read the first reading from Hosea 4:1-3 as the cries and mourning of the Earth and the prophet Hosea hears those cries. It points to our need to carefully hear the cries of the Earth community today and give them voice to those unable to listen to the Earth.

Hosea observes, that the land mourns over those who live in it languish. Rather the Earth mourns the subversion of God’s created order depicted poetically in the creation account in Genesis. This time creation is reversed, from humanity to wild animals, the birds of the air, and the fish of the sea. Israel. Now modern humanity, has upset the balance of God’s created order. So the Earth indicts humanity and mourns the degradation resulting from human destruction. Humanity has the destructive power and now the capability because our technology and industrial waste released into the atmosphere, into landfills, and into the oceans, we can undo the evolved created order of the evolution of a balanced Earth capable to support diverse life.

In Genesis 2, God gives humanity the mission to serve. God cares for all creation. How do we move from a human-centric perspective of acting towards the Earth to identify with the Earth community as siblings and seek the voices of the Earth community who are our sibling relatives?

There are several places in the scriptures to look for answer to my question. I want to look at Jesus an example. Certainly, Jesus was not aware of the environmental issues of today’s climate change, environmental degradation, and the extinction of species during his life. However, he had first-hand experience of domination by the Roman Empire and its colonization of Galilee and Judea. He witnessed the impact of conquest, spiraling indebtedness of peasants and their displacement from their farmlands, religious fundamentalism, and burdensome Roman and religious taxation, and so. Given the choice between domination and service, we see in the gospels that Jesus chose service. Here is his words in Mark 10:42-45)

You know that among the Gentiles those whom they recognize as their rulers lord it over them and their great ones are tyrants over them. But it is not among you: but whoever wishes to be first among you must be slave to all. For the Child of Humanity came not to be served but to serve and give his life as ransom for many.

Jesus’ commitment to service and compassionate care for the poor can be extended to the Earth and all life. Biblical scholar Norman Habel writes,

The way of Jesus –serving rather than dominating—clearly stands in tension with the mandate to dominate in Genesis 1. I would go so far as to say that the way of Jesus supersedes the mandate to dominate. (Habel, An Inconvenient Text)

The principle of Jesus is service as a slave. Jesus is freely choosing service as a slave, the lowest and humblest position in his society. His introduction of his disciples and his audience into the new ways of God’s reign is that of serving, not being served. Serving has the built-in notion of listening and caring for the needs of the “other.” Jesus chooses to serve rather than the path of domination and ruling.

He models for us in the 21st century how we might care for the Earth and its community of interrelated life. As the incarnation of God, Jesus models the most profound image of God. He defines God as who is other-centered in love and compassionate care.

I want to end with a story:

The Maori of New Zealand reenact the arrival of their ancestors from across the ocean more than a thousand years ago. They are confronted by four fierce guardians of the volcano, the ocean, the forest, and the wind. As they come unto the land, they hear the cry of mother Earth: will you be guardians of my land? Their call echoes the cry of the Earth in Genesis 2. Will you be my guardians? (Habel)

Indigenous peoples like the Maori are more in tune with listening to the voices of the Earth—the plants, the animals, ocean, forest, volcano, and wind. Indigenous peoples factor in their ability to co-live with the Earth; they focus their attentiveness on living with and maintaining the existence of other beings because other beings are our siblings and have the right to exist.

Brazilian theologian Leonardo Boff has spoken for the indigenous peoples of Brazil. He tells us modern folks we need to recover a shamanic consciousness:

Inside each of us lies the shaman dimension. That shaman energy causes us to stand speechless in the face of the immensity of the sea, to sense the eyes of another person, to be entranced on seeing a newborn child. We need to liberate the shaman dimension within us, so as to enter into harmony with all around us, and to feel at peace.

Will you follow Christ and use his principle of service to care for the Earth? Will you commit yourselves to be guardians of the Earth community this climate Sunday?

Join Me in the following Earth Covenant:

We, the MCC / United Church of Christ in the Valley, proclaim our love for God’s Creation and profess our belief that the Earth and all life are an interconnected part of the sacred Web of Life. We acknowledge we too are part of the Web of Life.

We covenant together to commit ourselves as a church and individuals in the great work of healing, preservation and justice as we strive to reduce our individual and collective negative impact on the environment and to repair the damage that has been done to God’s Earth. In worship and church life we will express our appreciation and give praise for the Earth and display a reverence for the Earth community of life. We commit ourselves to principles of taking only what we need, cleaning up our damage to Earth we do, and keeping the Earth in repair for the future.

We make this covenant in the hope and faith that through our Earth care we will be able to help improve and sustain the health of the land, air and water for the benefit of all current and future inhabitants of this Planet. Amen!

Friend of sinners (Lk. 7:33-35)

Jesus in the gospel reading is accused to be a “friend of sinners,” along with the charges of “a drunkard” and “a glutton.” Jesus also receives criticism of his feasting and not fasting like John the Baptist. A number of his parables describe banquets, weddings, parties, and celebrations, and it seems that he considered meals to be special occasions to enact the celebration of God’s unconditional love and forgiveness. The gospels, in particular Luke, portray Jesus going to meals or coming from them. His eating with sinners is mentioned frequently, and they form an important part of his ministry. Jesus scolds scribes and Pharisees for their table manners by taking the best seats. It is interesting that Jesus, who has no house of his own, enters another’s home and immediately takes over the household as the host of the meal.

The gospels associate him with disreputable people, tax collectors, sinners, and prostitutes. The scribes, connected to the Pharisees and the Temple priests, ask, “For what reason does he eat with tax collectors and sinners.” (Mk. 2:16) How do we answer the question?

Jesus first deliberately seeks out disreputable sinners and people; they are colorful folks. I understand that too well; overly religious people can be boring and snobbish. Disreputable people have colorful lives, they are interesting sinners. .
Secondly, have you ever noticed how righteous religious folks are always concerned about sin and sinners? This is true in Jesus’ time and our own. They are obsessed with sins of the flesh and ignore the sinful conditions that lead people into poverty and homelessness, the desperation of prostitution especially in patriarchal societies when women have little opportunity to earn a living. Or in our own time, the victims of war and disease, people denied basic human rights, undocumented workers, environmental degradation and racism, the exploitation of the planetary resources and consuming fossil fuels and releasing vast amounts of carbon and other toxic chemicals resulting in global warming.

I have a theory why self-righteous religious folks are concerned about sinners: First, it separates the pious from the sinner. Remember Jesus’ parable of the Pharisee and the tax collector.

To some who were confident of their own righteousness and looked down on everyone else, Jesus told this parable:   “Two men went up to the temple to pray, one a Pharisee and the other a tax collector.  The Pharisee stood by himself and prayed: ‘God, I thank you that I am not like other people—robbers, evildoers, adulterers—or even like this tax collector.  I fast twice a week and give a tenth of all I get.’

“But the tax collector stood at a distance. He would not even look up to heaven, but beat his breast and said, ‘God, have mercy on me, a sinner.’

“I tell you that this man, rather than the other, went home justified before God. For all those who exalt themselves will be humbled, and those who humble themselves will be exalted.” (Lk. 18:9-14)

You can just here the sneer in his voice as he looks down with despise at the tax collector. By putting someone down and separating yourself from them, you have made yourself better than those people.

The religious self-righteous always excuse themselves from the need for repentance when they compare themselves with what they consider as sinners, the wicked, or the impure outsider. The tax collector, however, never repents or reforms his life; he humbly acknowledges himself a sinner and asks God for mercy. Jesus commends the tax collector who is a sinner.

Jesus ate and drank with sinners; he was proud of the title—“friend of sinners.” Jesus says, “Truly, I say to you that tax collectors and prostitutes will get into the kingdom of God before you.” ( Mt, 21:31) Jesus claimed that sinners were closer to the reign of God than the righteous religious people. But I want you to pay attention to the fact that Jesus seldom tells individual sinners to repent or reform their lives. He never concentrates on sexual sinners of prostitutes nor does the expected extortion and corruption of tax collectors.

There is only one story where Jesus says to the women caught in adultery. He defends the woman from her male accusers whose hearts are hardened against he. Jesus writes in the sand, indicating the law is written in sand and not hardened in stone. He tells the accusers, “Let anyone among you without sin throw the first stone.” The self-righteous accusers fade away, and Jesus comments,

“Has anyone condemned you?” She says, “No one sir.” Neither do I condemn you. Go your way, and from now on do not sin again.” (Jn 8:10-11)

The earliest manuscripts of John’s gospel does not have this story, and it was added as a floating story that made second or third generation followers of Jesus uncomfortable at his compassion with sexual sins. I suspect “from now on do not sin again” was added by a scribe in John’s community. Why do I say this? It does not fit in portrait of Jesus and his relationship with sinners in the other three gospels. It seems a third generation Christian addition when Christians were trying to prove that they were very moral to fit in the Roman Empire.

The other three gospels portray Jesus as befriending sinners with requiring repentance. Jesus generally does not single out common sinners, and his call to repentance is a generalized call to repentance to society in the opening of Mark’s gospel: “The time is fulfilled and the reign of God has drawn near. Repent and believe in the good news.” (Mk. 1:15)

Jesus frequently directed his message of repentance at the scribes, Pharisees, Sabbath fundamentalists, and or Temple priests or religious folks of high status. He engages actively in conflict with them, criticizing hypocrisy, religious abuse, oppression of the poor and the elderly, and the rich. He condemns such behaviors that abuse power or exploits the poor and the vulnerable. He challenges Sabbath fundamentalists who are upset with his violation of the Sabbath law to heal the afflicted or those lacking compassion for the sick and the poor. Jesus affirms that common sinners will enter God’s reign before them.

There is no question that Jesus upset the religious self-righteous and powerful because he did not require sinners to repent in the traditional manner of sin offering sacrifices. Jesus tells his holy critics, “Go and learn what this means, ‘I desire mercy, not sacrifice.’” (Mt. 9:11) On one level, Jesus is criticizing his accusers for their lack of compassion, and on another, he challenges their exclusionary practices and requirements for sin offerings. God’s forgiveness is already there in his meals celebrating God’s unconditional love.

Sinners and self-righteous both called Jesus “friend of sinners.” A closer look at the term helps to understand what is really going on when he does not require repentance of common sinners. He invited sinners into fellowship with himself to celebrate God’s forgiveness of sins. I want to share a quotation from the book Sinners by Greg Carey:

Jesus’ companionship with sinners opened the path for people to challenge his uprightness. Some people, perhaps many people, believed that a respectable religious leader like Jesus had no business cavorting with sinners. Yet Jesus identified himself with sinners. And some sinners joined his movement. That is how the Gospels tell it, perhaps, because early generations of Christians identified with the sinners of the stories.

So “friend of sinners” not only a title given to Jesus and his ministry, it also was his method of reaching out to sinners and bringing the good news of God’s unconditional acceptance and forgiveness of them.

I have left discussion of centering prayer reading from Sinners until last. The boy Brian imitates his father’s violence and threats of his mother by pulling a gun out of the gun cabinet and placing the barrel his mother’s chin, saying “If you say another word, I’ll blow your fucking head off.” Brian imitates his father’s violence with his sister over eating the last of the cereal and takes a gun and shoots his sister dead. His action is horrific, and he is sent to a youth home for his crime. A counselor tells him one day that he is a neat kid. Brian replied, “you wouldn’t say that if you knew why I am here!” And the counsellor said, “Of course, I do; we all do.” And Brian breaks down sobbing confronted with unconditional love and acceptance.

Jesus chose the method of companioning with sinners; he did not have to require them to repent. He proclaimed that God had forgiven them. They were beloved children of God, and God accepted them unconditionally, forgave them unconditionally, and love them without any string attached.

For Jesus’ critics, his companioning with sinners was offensive because it violated the purity laws with which they wrapped up their religious self-righteousness. Sin is after all very contagious; it will spread like a disease unless we guard against it. He proclaimed God’s forgiveness to them without requiring them to reform their lives with the traditional means of paying for a sin offering at the Temple. In fact, Jesus celebrated with sinners God’s forgiveness and unconditional acceptance in his meals; they celebrated God’s presence and forgiveness dining together.

Does the method of becoming a friend of sinners without repentance work? Many of his disciples were sinners—Levi the tax collector, Simon the Zealot, and Mary Magdalene. They changed the directions of their lives and became disciples as they experienced the blessing of God’s unconditional love and forgiveness. They changed their lives because they encountered God as love.

We companion with people who are hurt, oppressed, different, undocumented, and considered outcasts because our mission as disciples to become vehicles of God’s unconditional love to others. Often people change their lives by the radical unconditional love from God, and we become disciples to make the mission of Jesus as friend of sinners alive today. But we also are very conscious that we too miss the mark often and that we too are sinners but live with the climate of God’s extravagant love and grace. Many sinners, including myself, became followers of Christ as we felt God’s tender mercies and unconditional love for us.

As we read in the First Letter of John 4:7-11,
Beloved, let us love one another, because love is from God. Whoever does not love does not know God, for God is love. God’s love is was revealed among us in this way: God sent God’s only Child into the world, so that we might live through hi. In this love, not that we loved God but that God loved us and sent God’s Child…. Beloved since God loved us so much, we also ought to love one another.
Jesus gave us an example of loving our enemies with unconditional love despite their hostility to us. God send us into places where are considered sinful because there we can be companions to the one Christ who was a friend of sinners.

Go and companion with sinners. Be friends and exude the unconditional love of God has for all sorts of sinners.

“Christ is Never without Water” (Mk: 1: 7-11)

The 2nd century North African Christian writer, Tertullian, wrote, “Christ is never without water.” Of course, you can say that Jesus’ body contained 60-65% water as an adult. I believe that it is significant that we as adults all contain water averaging between 55-65% of our bodies. New born infants contain about 75% water. Water is as important as blood in our bodies. And all life is connected with water.

In fact, the entire Bible is full of water images, for water plays a vital role from creation to the crossing of the Jordan River to the baptism of Jesus. There is a vital interconnection between water and all life for flourishing and survival. Water and its relationship to God in the Bible suggest the care of the Creator for creation, and water becomes the potential site of engagement with God’s Spirit. We frequently encounter God in or near water.

Today’s gospel reading narrates the story when Jesus is baptized in the waters of the Jordan River by John the Baptism Let me look at the baptism of Jesus. Jesus’ baptism by John the Baptist has made Christians uncomfortable, for John baptized folks for the forgiveness of sins. Christians have been uncomfortable that Jesus was baptized for the forgiveness of his sins. They have had to rationalize Jesus’ baptism. For example, the 4th century bishop of Alexandria Athanasius declares: “When the Lord, as man, was washed in the Jordan, it was we who were washed in him and by him.” Athanasius shifts the focus of the baptism to Jesus representing humanity in the waters of baptism. That may be a good theological after thought.

However, if we look carefully at the baptism of Jesus, it is more than John’s baptism for forgiveness of personal sins. When Jesus merges from being immersed in the waters and as he grasps for breath, he experiences an epiphany of God. It is a revelation whereby God in the form of dove or the Spirit descends upon Jesus in the Jordan waters with these words: “You are my beloved child with whom I am well pleased.”

Jesus is born from the cosmic waters of the Jordan as the Spirit hovered over the waters of creation in Genesis. Jesus is born as the beloved child from heaven and earth. His baptism inaugurated his ministry of the reign of God. The Spirit’s descent upon Jesus as he emerged from the water dripping down his forehead, beard, and his hair wet transforms him into the beloved child of God. It was the Spirit who overshadowed the womb of Mary as Jesus was conceived. It is now the Spirit who transforms Jesus with God’s grace into the beloved child of God, commissioned to preach God’s kingdom in our midst. And Jesus’ baptism gives a new content to the baptism for forgiveness of John the Baptist.

There seems to be a very strong correlation between the water of baptism and water for daily use. The water of baptism represents life, the grace of God, renewal and hope. What better natural symbol for God’s life-giving grace! The yearning of Christians for baptismal water at whatever cost reflects an equally deep yearning in us for water for ordinary use. Our thirst for water is great metaphor for our thirst for the Spirit.

Jesus—as God’s incarnation—unites heaven and earth in himself. He is interconnected with the waters of creation and all life, and this is made clear in a theological insight by Edward Echlin:

When Jesus enter the Jordan, the waters and creatures dependent upon water, re sanctified by the presence of God’s word made flesh. All waters are connected—water is like the blood of the earth. All waters are cosmic. Sanctified, recreated, when the Spirit again moves of the waters at the Jordan at Jesus’ baptism.

If all waters are connected through the baptism of the beloved child of the earth and heaven, I like to repeat Tertullian’s observation: ‘Christ is never without water.” Christ’s grace—like living water– reaches every pore of our bodies, the bodies of creatures and plant-life, into the soils of the earth, with the rains from heaven falling on to the soil, in the wells and oasis streams, in bubbling springs and rivers, lakes, and the oceans that comprised much of our planet. The orthodox Syrian bishop Jacob of Serugh claims that “our Lord went down to the Jordan, and the whole of nature of water stirred with joy.” Many Christian writers have comprehended the baptism of Jesus as the beginning of the new creation. They understood water as an ever present symbol of God’s grace in Christ.

God’s grace is there in our baptism whether the waters are sprinkled on your forehead or you are immersed in the waters. You are immersed in the grace life of God. You become part of the body of Christ—connected by the Spirit to the Earth and all life and adopted as beloved children of Abba God. We and all life become virtual baptismal waters of Christ. We are Christ’s virtual water. The Holy Spirit is always about change, new life and transformations through grace, union with Christ and all creation.

Echlin again writes,

The faith of the church, with which baptized Christians are entrusted includes appreciation of the world’s waters, and the virtual water of the soil, because, in Jesus, God descended into the living Jordan, setting the waters afire. (Echlin)
All the waters of the Earth were set afire by the Spirit, the Spirit connected Christ to all waters.

Let me take your through a tour of the gospels of Jesus and water. It tells us much about Jesus’ baptismal ministry and our water discipleship.
But I think of all those places in the gospels where Jesus and water interact. I want to do a quick water tour of the gospel to understand the ministry of Jesus and its connection to water.

First there is Jesus walking on the waters of Sea of Galilee and invites Peter to join him, and of course, Peter sinks like a rock. Or there is Jesus, who awakes from a sleep in the boat with his disciples during a storm and calms the storm. Jesus is connected to the water ways of Galilee, its wells and streams, and beyond: the Jordan River and Sea of Galilee. By the shore of the Sea of Galilee, Jesus feeds five thousand plus folks with the multiplication of the loaves and the fish.

In John’s gospel, Jesus and water are connected more than any other gospel. There is Jesus first miracle at the Wedding of Cana, where he turns large barrels of water into wine. Water is transformed into wine for the merriment and joy of a wedding banquet. Weddings are fertile.

With the secret visit of Nicodemus at night, Jesus tells him: “No one can enter the kingdom of God without being born of water and Spirit.” (Jn. 3:5) He connects water and Spirit together in a spiritual rebirth for the closeted disciple Nicodemus. The primal waters of creation are connected to the hovering of the Spirit, and ever since the symbolism of water for Spirit has been part of the Jewish and Christian traditions. The Spirit is the midwife of creation bringing life and renewed energy.

And in the next chapter, there is the marvelous scene between Jesus and the Samaritan woman at the well, telling the woman if she knew the gift of God, and who it is that is saying to you, “Give me a drink,’ you would have asked him, and he would have given you living water.” (Jn. 4:10) Jesus goes on to say: “Whoever drinks of the water that I will give him will never be thirsty again. The water that I will give him will become in him a spring of water welling up to eternal life.” (Jn. 4:14)

In the discourse between Jesus and the Samaritan woman (John 4:7-15), we see the Samaritan woman asking for the living waters. Yes, she needed the water from Jacob’s well, but she also needed the living water even more. God gives Jesus to the world as the water of life, and Jesus offers himself to the world as the living water. This living water figuratively represents a blessing that reproduces itself, and like a spring, it is never exhausted. Through those suffering from water poverty, Christ in person of the poor is still begging for something to drink, for water, for the living water. Are we willing to share a cup of living water. In the upcoming season of Lent, as we deny ourselves comforts in order to feel the pain of others, may we come up with practical ways of standing in solidarity with the many who are still crying, give us water … the living waters! We might practice a little further personal restraint in our over consumption of water. The average American uses 100 gallons per day while the Navajo uses 7 gallons.

Water was scarce in Jesus’ day, yet water was as much a necessity for life then as it is today. Half of the world’s population today lives in arid regions where is not readily available nor clean water accessible. Just as the physical body needs water to continue living so does humanity and all life needs the water of the Spirit.

Jesus at the Festival of Booths in Jerusalem proclaims: “Let anyone who is thirsty come to me, and let the one who believes in me drink. As the scripture has said, ”Out of the believer’s heart shall flow rivers of living water.” (Jn. 7:37-38) The heart is the place of faith, for when we place our hearts in God, we connect to God, heart to heart. Jesus’ prophecy comes true, for when he dies on the cross and the centurion stabs Jesus in the chest with his lance, water and blood flow from the open wound on the dead body of Jesus. Water and Spirit are identified earlier in the gospel, and the gospel takes the flow of water with blood as a fulfillment of Jesus’ earlier prophecy that rivers of living water will flow from his heart. Jesus’ glorification by Abba God has begun with death, for he handed over his Spirit. Jesus says earlier in John, “When you lift of the Child of Humanity, then you will realize that I AM.” (Jn. 8:28 f) And the water represents the beginning of his pouring out his Spirit.

There is a Homeric legend in the Iliad that the gods did not have blood in their veins but a type of blood mixed with water. In epic poem, Aphrodite– in combat before the city of Troy–is wounded, and she bleeds a mixture of water and blood. And this signifies the divinity of Aphrodite. This is how Gentile converts would understand the stabbing the side of Jesus.

At the Last Supper, Jesus strips off his cloak, and like a slave or woman, he washes the feet of his disciples. This act of foot washing has often been connected to baptism and the death of Jesus. Jesus performed this servile action to prophesy that he would be humiliated in death. He has acted out a parable of humble service for his disciples which they must be prepared to imitate. He is reminding them “no servant is more important than his master.” Christians have connected baptism to the death of Jesus, his resurrection, and his gift of the Spirit. If we die with Christ in the waters of baptism, we are baptized into the risen Christ.In Mark’s gospel, Jesus is asked by his disciples where he wants to celebrate the Passover. He gives this very strange instruction:

Go into the city, and a man carrying a jar of water will meet you, follow him, and wherever he enters, say to the owner of the house. “The Teacher asks, “Where is my guest room where I may eat the Passover with my disciples?” (Mk. 14:13-14)

It would have been socially improper for a man to do this type of women’s work of drawing water and carrying it back to his master. Some commentators have said this is the equivalent in our times of Jesus instructing the disciples to look for the gender bending man—cross-dressing, wearing a wig and with make-up. While it would be anachronistic to suggest this man may have been queer-identified in our modern sense, he was certainly transgressing a strict gendered boundary in his behavior. Jesus seems to be aware of this gender variant man. It is interesting to speculate about his relationship with the man carrying the water jar.

My inclusive imagination goes wild over these couple of lines in Mark’s gospel. Was there a location in Jerusalem where one met gender variant males? Jesus was certainly comfortable with eunuchs when identifies with eunuchs in his statement: “For there are eunuchs who have been so from birth, and there are eunuchs who have been made eunuchs by men, and there are eunuchs who have made themselves eunuchs for the sake of the kingdom of heaven.”(Mt. 19:12)

If so, it points to Jesus’ inclusive experience of these gender variant males and eunuchs, and more importantly, his inclusion of gender variant folks into his ministry is wider than we could even imagine. Did Jesus and his disciples eat his Last Supper in a location that would scare many religiously conservative and purity conscious Pharisees would cringe at the thought?

Jesus preached while sharing a cup of water; he fed 5000 near the waters of the Sea of Galilee, he described himself as the living water. He healed the blind at pool of Siloam and instructed him to wash his eyes from the waters of the pool.
Water symbolizes the transformation born of us as children of God into a new creation—an inclusive community connected to the waters within the cosmic Christ. Next time you take a drink of water, understand that you drink the waters of Christ. It is a form of communion, and you have born like Christ as child of heaven and earth. And the water you drink connects you to all water and life.
Finally, when we were baptized, we understand that we were baptized with Christ and into the mystical body of Christ. We become beloved children of heaven and earth, and we have a responsibility for the waters of the Earth and all the life containers carrying virtual water of Christ. Our water discipleship is born of our baptism. And we honor the Christ in all waters have a responsibility to water justice around–to make sure all have access to water and clean water.   Water justice starts with us and our conservation here in Southern California even on a rainy weekend!

Ancestral Grace: Incarnation Continues On

Today Gospel is the Prologue to the Gospel of John. It was probably a Christian hymn in John’s community to celebrate the event of God’s incarnation in Christ. When I reflect on the mysteries of Christ’s life, I ask a question what is salvific in Christ: Is it hs Incarnation, his life and ministry, his crucifixion, or Christ’s resurrection from the dead? I could make an argument for each event listed or take the easily route, claiming “all” these form a picture of what God was doing in the birth, ministry and message of Jesus, his confrontations in Jerusalem, his death and resurrection.
Walter Wink, a gospel scholar, writes:

When Jesus appeared on the scene, the collective unconscious of the age was fully prepared. His life tapped into the massive psychic upheaval that was affecting numerous groups, not only in Judaism but in the Mediterranean world generally. Something seismic was about to happen, and Jesus stood at the epicenter.

This precisely sums up my feelings of what was being revealed in the Christian gospels. God’s incarnation in Jesus is seismic, yet he is born an outsider, outside Bethlehem and outside human abode—a stable or cave. The ancestral grace of creation was bearing fruition of a divine intention of God wll before the universe was created to share divine love and community with others than God’s self. It is the story of the beginnings of our universe, our story and the story of all life as well. God intended to create the universe, teeming with life, but God anticipated that God would disturb this world with God’s self by taking on physical embodiment. This the divine intention to find communion or union together with the universe.

Jesus, in the totality of his existence as a human and beyond both in his incarnation and resurrection, embodies a divine potential within our humanity and mature growth. One of my favorite authors Diarmuid O’Murchu quotes the Canadian theologian Gregory Baum: “God is what happens to a person on the way to becoming human.”

Jesus says, “I am the way…” because he is the gateway for us to become divine. And the paradox is that the path to becoming divine is to become more fully human as Jesus manifested his humanity. Jesus points out that humans are not made for perfection as claimed by the church for centuries, but that we are graced for the wholeness of Christ through our relationship to the risen Christ and, in turn, to God. Think about the phrase, I used, we are “graced for the wholeness of Christ through our relationship to the risen Christ.”

The Spirit lures us with all our brokenness into a love relationship with Christ and helps us to realize that God’s incarnation in human flesh is not only about Jesus but all flesh united with the Spirit who now has given birth to Christ within themselves. The God/human is thoroughly divine and thoroughly human. And that is the good news and the scandal of the incarnation. At this Christmas season, we name God’s incarnation in Jesus as “Immanuel”–“God with us.” God is with us and in us. We incarnate or embody God’s Christ within us, and that is a revelation to us.

Unfortunately, the church for the most of its history stressed “Jesus saves or rescues us.” But I want to tell you that Jesus is more than “savior.” Jesus the rescuer must be replaced with a wider notion of Jesus the Christ, who is the icon of God’s compassion, unconditional love, and forgiveness and grace. Jesus is God’s selfless communication of divine love to us, and there is so much to Jesus the Christ as the communication of God’s unconditional love. God’s love through Christ and the Spirit goes well beyond saving us, for God’s love graces our humanity, that is opens to the pouring the divine life of Christ within us. And that grace of Christ within our bodies and within ourselves transforms us to the core of our being by making us siblings of Christ and children of God.

The Church has suffocated Jesus through the ages: with unhealthy stresses and distortions that made power and wealth church goals; a perfectionism that is unhealthy and disincarnational, denying the our bodies and sexuality as original blessings; domination and exploitation of the Earth and other life with callousness and heartlessness; views of sin originating from legalism, guilt, and shaming; an exclusivism that Jesus fought against and gave up his life; a Christian fundamentalism that tries to control people and access to God; literalist readings of scripture over religious imagination when Jesus spoke in parable and metaphor and re-enacted symbol actions of God presence in our midst. Why stay with such a dysfunctional institution? Great question—you may want to ask this on a regular basis.

Does the church follow Christ or follow its own wayward path? Pope Francis delivered his Christmas message to cardinals and bishops in the Vatican bureaucracy speaking in very strong terms that the leadership of the church suffers a “spiritual Alzheimer’s.” We have been engaged in a cultural and religious war between the above forces against our ancestral notions that God’s creation, incarnation, and the energy of Spirit is one continuous flow of divine grace and love, surrounding us and living within us, and freeing us to serve God’s people with gratitude and joy. We hear echoes of the cultural/religious war in the words of today’s gospel:

What has come into being in him was life, and the life and the light of all people. The light shines in the darkness, and the darkness did not overcome it.
Or,
He came to what was his own, and his own people did not accept him. But to all who received him, who placed their hearts in his name, he gave them power to become the children of God.

These are the everyday struggles we experience in our world and in our churches as we hold to an ancestral grace that we are God’s children and siblings of Jesus the Christ. But other church agendas distract us from the good news of God’s incarnation.

Ancestral grace is what we may describe as the divine matrix of love from which all creation was born. It is the most primal impulse and energy of love within the whole universe. It is the divine milieu of unconditional love, our relatedness to God, our interconnections with all life and the Spirit of God within all life. Through this ancestral grace, we recognize that we are siblings with all peoples and especially, those who are different from ourselves and those in need. We are siblings with the Earth and all life on the Earth. Grace is the ocean of divine love where we realize abundance, our original blessedness as children of God, our reason for existence, working for the gospel, living compassionately, and caring in the world. Gratitude, a word originating from the word “grace,” expresses our thanksgiving and gratefulness to God’s continued “gifting” to us. Gratitude emerges from God’s grace as a natural response of ‘Saying thanks.”

We cannot define this grace, but we know it when we live within the stream of God’s abundant grace surrounding us and flowing within us.
A little known historical fact is that images of the crucified Jesus on the cross did not appear until 965 CE in the Cathedral of Cologne (now Germany). Prior to this introduction of the crucifix, Christians were devoted to the cross—in earliest time Egyptian ankh as a disguised cross or the Greek letter “Tau” or “T” in the first couple of centuries of Christianity. Christians called themselves “devotees of the cross.” The risen and glorified image of Jesus was placed on the cross. The stress of Christians was placed on the resurrected Christ, not the tortured Christ on the cross. They recognized that ancestral grace burst forth on Easter in the risen Christ. The God of life transformed the deadly element of the cross into the resurrected life. God’s incarnation– that was intended before the advent of time and the big bang explosion into universe– came to its fruition in the risen life of the Incarnate God.

Jesus points the path forward towards this ancestral grace that reached its fruition in the resurrection. Resurrection life is wider than the risen Christ because it models what we human beings will become from the ancestral grace of divine love unleashed in creation. We call this unleashing of divine love the Holy Spirit—who harnesses the power of resurrection for us and all life. St. Paul describes Jesus as the “first born,” the “new Adam” because he embodies what we will become in the future—divinized by the power of resurrection and humanized to our greatest potential by God’s love and grace. Jesus as the “new Adam” means he is the prototype of a new race, the first born of humanity and all life destined to live in a graced relationship with God. What is this ancestral grace expressed here when we speak of Jesus as the pioneer of new life or a new creation? It means ancestral grace is the grace of the risen life of Jesus.
Jesus invites us into resurrected life as co-creators, working with the Spirit to bring the messiness of human living, the struggles we all face, the flaws of our lives—knowing that our relationship with the risen Christ and the Spirit will provide the love and motivation for us to mature in our grace-filled humanity. We are graced by the risen Christ. Our humanity is transformed by our relationship with the risen Christ.

What does it mean to live in a graced relationship with God in Christ? I have shifted the terms with which you have grown up in Christian churches —“rescued and saved” to the transformed and amzing notion of resurrected and risen. Salvation is about our transformation, graced into the divine life of triune community of love. This is what resurrection means—graced companionship and participation in the risen life of Christ. We move beyond the guilt and shame model of being rescued to the graced relationship with the risen Christ. This means we no longer beat ourselves up when we fall back into our flaws and failings but listen to our companion the risen Christ who encourages us that we are not alone but that he is with us.

Here is what I believe that companionship in ancestral grace means:
It first means that Christ lives in and through us—God with us, Emmanuel:
This is the incarnational prayer of Teresa of Avila:

Christ has no body but yours,
No hands, no feet on earth but yours,
Yours are the eyes with which he looks
Compassion on this world,
Yours are the feet with which he walks to do good,
Yours are the hands, with which he blesses all the world.
Yours are the hands, yours are the feet,
Yours are the eyes, you are his body.
Christ has no body now but yours,
No hands, no feet on earth but yours,
Yours are the eyes with which he looks
compassion on this world.
Christ has no body now on earth but yours.

We become incarnated presence of the risen Christ; we continue to be the arms; legs and feet of Christ in the world, eyes and ears of Christ; we become the heart of Christ making compassion and forgiveness of Christ real in the world. We are beings in a graced relationship, and we put Christ on and live

And there is a child born outside of Bethlehem….

T.S. Eliot wrote in ‘Four Quartets’, “Humankind cannot bear too much reality.” So we divert ourselves from the true message of Christmas either by romanticizing the story of the birth of Jesus or by replacing it with our mythologies of about the magic of Santa Claus, Rudolph the Red Nose Reindeer, or Frosty the Snowman. Because of secularists and atheist protests, we nervously mention Christmas trees or avoid public displays of the nativity story because it offends somebody. The gospel nativity stories have become a casualty of our cultural wars.

But our Advent hope lies in the scandalous promise that God will become one of us. “The Word will become flesh.” But is the most amazing event that startles us. The ‘reign of God’ will come when God embraces us in all our strange and paradoxical reality, and we embrace ourselves and one another with all our human contradictions and weaknesses.

Augustus Caesar ordered a census for the purpose of taxation. Counting the number of conquered subjects and taxing them was Rome’s imperial destiny to collect taxes for the divine Emperor. We always presume that there is one Davidic descendant, Joseph. But I suspect that there were a number of Davidic descendants or would-be claimants crowding the inns of Bethlehem. All the private and semi-private rooms around the courtyards were already taken. And there were no room for the couple from Nazareth in the inns of Bethlehem.

So Mary gives birth to her child outside of the town. God affects the birth of Jesus outside of the economic, political, and religious order. Cities and towns were imperial sites for taxation and rule. The Magi have to search and follow a star to discover this child whereas the shepherds find the child accessible to themselves outside the gates of town and city in a barn or cave housing for animals. Jesus is born among the domesticated animals in an open courtyard.
Jesus is born outside of the Roman census; his birth is undocumented and remains unrecorded. We do not know the time of the day or even the day or even the year that Jesus was born. It is guess-work or theological reflection from the second century CE that dates it at the time of the winter solstice when the longest nights and shortest days take place. “And there a light was born in the darkness and the darkness did not overcome it.”

The birth of Roman rulers were precisely recorded: the time of day, the date and place of their births, and the births of the children of Herod the Great were likewise recorded—but not the “word become flesh” remains in story but not in any official documents. Jesus is literally born outside of the established political order; he is born an outsider, a nomad whose destiny was to live on the borders of his society and eventually to die outside the political capital of Jerusalem. And again we know the season Jesus will be crucified is springtime at Passover, but we do not know the exact year he died. Sometime between 27-30 CE.

“This will be a sign for you; you will find a child wrapped in bands of cloth and lying in a manger.” The child is laid in a manger suggesting a place where animals are housed. St. Francis of Assisi rightly understood that Jesus’ birth with animals housed in the stable/cave and that Jesus laid in a manager had significance. Francis was the first Christian to create a Christmas crèche with animals, for he comprehended the universal connections of the infant Jesus with animal life. All life had the same divine parent and thus all life is siblings. Jesus was not born fro humanity only but for the whole world—all beings of God’s creation.

Jesus’ birth does takes place at the margins of society but outside of society in the uncivilized world, and it begins a story that repeats itself over and over in his ministry and life. He is an outsider his life, an outsider to the religious establishment in Jerusalem, and is political outsider on the cross outside Jerusalem.

God is born an outsider to human civilization but an insider to the world. Religious scholar Karen Armstrong observes, “If we study the Christmas story carefully, we are left with the disturbing sense that the world’s future lies with the very people cast to its margins.” It is a story of an outsider for all those whoever felt outside of society and alienated from religion. It is given to the wealthy and privileged as an opportunity to hear what they most forget about themselves and their world. God has become an outsider.

What the birth of Jesus allows us to imagine God become human. We see it in him how the divine and the human are woven forever one. God did not just take on one human nature. God took on all human nature and said “yes” to it forever! God took on everything physical, material, and natural as himself. That is the full meaning of the Incarnation, the humanity of God—God with us. The story of Christmas announces that where there are poor and disadvantaged people, there is Jesus. From his birth until stripped and dying on the cross, Jesus identified with the poor and oppressed. There is no Christianity without care for the poor and the suffering, and that includes the Earth and all life.

And that’s the whole point! You and I are simultaneously children of heaven and children of earth, divine and human coexisting in a well hidden disguise. We are a living paradox, just as Jesus was. We also are a seeming contradiction that is not a contradiction at all. Most Christians were simply never told the real good news that flesh and spirit, divine and human, coexist in a wondrous mystery. That was not made clear in Jesus and surely not in ourselves by the church. The consequences of not fully acceptance of “the word became flesh and dwelled among us” have been disastrous at all levels of notions of human perfection and exclusion of the less perfect” the pure and impure, saved and sinner. God’s incarnation did not happen in the pregnancy of Mary but the ancient unfathomable time of 15 billion years ago when the big bang happened. God fused Godself with the gases and the atomic particles that would be shaped in the womb of Mary, given birth to a child– who would experience the fullness of human life, all its joys, tragedies, and disappointment. The child—born of heaven and earth– would discover divine nature within himself and within the world.

Matter always reveals Spirit, and Spirit lies hidden as the divine energy within all that is physical, material, earthly, human, fleshy and erotic, flawed, and failing. Everything is a sacrament of the divine presence! Nothing else could truly be called good news. We learn the real meaning of human life, compassionately interconnected with the web of life, by meditating upon the life of Jesus and following in the footsteps of Jesus.

Let me quote extensively the Letter of the Divine Child authored by Brazilian theologian Leonardo Boff:

Christmas is the feast of children and of the Divine Child that hides within every adult. The belief that God came near to humankind in the form of a child is enormously inspiring. Thus no one can claim that it is just an unfathomable mystery, fascinating on the one hand and terrifying on the other. No. He came close to us in the fragility of a newborn who whimpered from the cold and hungrily sought the maternal breast. We have to respect and love this form in which God chose to enter our world, through the rear, in a grotto of animals, on a dark and snowy night, “because there was no room for him in the inns of Bethlehem.”

Even more consoling is the idea that we will be judged by a child and not by a stern and scrutinizing judge. What a child wants is to play. He immediately forms an affinity with other children, poor, rich, Asian, black, or blond…He is original since;

if you are able to make the hidden child be reborn in your parents, your uncles and aunts and other people you know so that love, tenderness, and caring for the whole world and also for nature well up in them;
if when looking at the manger you discover Jesus, poorly clad, almost naked, and you remember how many children are equally poorly clothed, and this situation wounds you to the bottom of your hearts, and you can share your surplu

innocence because he does not yet know the maliciousness of adult life.

The Divine Child will introduce us into the celestial dance and the banquet that the divine family of Father/Mother, Son and Holy Spirit has prepared for all its sons and daughters, without excluding those who once were torn by suffering.
I was reflecting on this blessed situation when an angel like those who sang to the shepherds in the fields of Bethlehem approached me spiritually and gave me a Christmas card. From whom could it be? I began to read. It said:

“Dear little brothers and sisters:

If when looking at the nativity and seeing the Child Jesus there between Mary and Joseph, next to the ox and the mule, you are filled with faith that God became a child like any one of you;

if you are able to see in other boys and girls the ineffable presence of Jesus the Child, who once was born in Bethlehem and has never left us alone in the world

if you are able to make the hidden child be reborn in your parents, your uncles and aunts and other people you know so that love, tenderness, and caring for the whole world and also for nature well up in them;

if when looking at the manger you discover Jesus, poorly clad, almost naked, and you remember how many children are equally poorly clothed, and this situation wounds you to the bottom of your hearts, and you can share your surplus and want to change this state of affairs right now;

if when seeing the cow, the donkey, the sheep, the goats, the dogs, the camels and the elephant in the nativity, you think that the whole universe is also lit by the Divine Child and that we are all part of the Great House of God;
if you look up to the heavens and see the star with its luminous tail and remember that there is always a star like the one of Bethlehem over you, that accompanies you, shines on you, and shows you the best paths;
if you remember that the Three Kings who came from far off lands, were really wise men and that still today they represent the scientists and teachers who are able to see the secret meaning of life and the universe in this Child;

if you believe that this Child is simultaneously (Hu)man and God, that, being (Hu)man, He is your brother and, being God, a part of God exists in you, and therefore you are filled with joy and real pride;
if you believe all this, know that I am born again and Christmas has come anew among you. I will always be near, walking with you, weeping with you and playing with you, until the day when all — humankind and universe — reach the House of God, who is Father and Mother of infinite goodness, to live together forever and be eternally happy.
Bethlehem. December 25, Year 1,
Signed The Divine Child Jesus

This Christmas my wish for you is to step into the heart of the scandal and mystery of the God-word became flesh and living within you.

Merry Christmas! 2014

Our Joy: Discovery of the Now (3rd Sunday of Advent, Luke 3:1-8)

This joyful spirit is marked by the third candle of our Advent wreath, which is rose color. Let me start with a prayer from Henri Nouwen for this third Sunday of Advent:
Lord Jesus, Master of both the light and the darkness, send your Holy Spirit upon our preparations for Christmas.
We who have so much to do seek quiet spaces to hear your voice each day.
We who are anxious over many things look forward to your coming among us.
We who are blessed in so many ways long for the complete joy of your kingdom.
We whose hearts are heavy seek the joy of your presence.
We are your people, walking in darkness, yet seeking the light.
To you we say, “Come Lord Jesus!”

This Christmas we need to pray with longing hearts, “Come Lord Jesus!” to experience the joy of this Advent.

We are simple in our correlation of happiness and joy and the opposite. When things are good in my life, God is good. When things are bad in my life, God is missing, or I have done something that prevents God from being present to myself. God’s presence, however, is not correlated with our emotional states. God is present whether we are happy or whether we experience life as going poorly. God’s love is not conditional. The joy of Advent does not simply happen to us.

God call us to a relationship with God’s self. It requires a relationship with God whether I am experiencing life as good or not so good. Our relationship with God journeys through the beautiful and painful parts of life. It doesn’t take a break.

God is not Santa Claus, checking whether we are good or bad, naughty or nice. When God enters relationship with us, it is for the long duration despite whether we turn our backs on God and Christmas or embrace Christmas. God is not good to us only in the times where we feel it and notice it. God is good to us all the time. God is present to us all the time and love us continuously.

Advent is practice of waiting for Jesus to come. “Joy to the world, the Lord is come. Let earth receive her King. Let every heart prepare Him room and Heaven and nature sing.” God has come and when I choose to live in this truth that Christ has come, I live with hope that we will be restored, that we will live in God’s peace. God loves me all the time. We have journeyed together and we will continue. God will never leave, and I have no need to be afraid. In the moments where I realize this and choose to believe this, despite what all may be going wrong…something deep in my soul smiles. Something deep in me rests. And there is peace.

I may not be content with what is going on, but I rest in the truth that I am loved by God. This is joy to me. Jesus coming to earth as a man, living a life of humility, extending friendship to those on the margins; this is joy! The truth that we have another way, that we can live in a way that breaks oppression and extends love; this is joy! Learning to live in the broken places, amidst injustice, loving those who are hurting, and seeing the face of God in those around you…this, this is joy of God’s incarnation. It is not just once a long time ago; God’s incarnated one continues to be incarnated in the now moment, before us, in faces around us, faces in need.

How do I reach this joy? I choose joy right now. Let me tell you a Zen Buddhist story: There was an ordinary person, like you and myself, who asked his Zen teacher whether he would write a few sentences of his wisdom. The Zen teacher took his paint brush and wrote the “Be Mindful.” The person asked is that all? Would he not write more? The Zen Teacher wrote again, “Be mindful.” The person was disappointed in what his teacher wrote. Now the Zen Teacher wrote it a third time, and he said, “Be Mindful means be mindful now!”

To be attentive in the now is the simplest thing in the world and yet the hardest thing to teach another. Thich Nhat Hanh reminds us that there are many ways do things but we seldom just do in the present moment. Being mindful and being present to a beloved person in my life or the stranger in need rests in our attentiveness in the present moment. Thich Nhat Hanh notes, “When you are being carried off by your sorrow, your fear, or your anger, you cannot really be present to the people and things you love!” The focus is to be attentive to the present moment; it is moment of grace; it is the moment of the discovery of a full relationship with God who has arrived. Thich Nhat Hanh has dedicated his life to help people experience the present moment, and he exemplifies this by his beatific smile. He says: “Sometimes your joy is the source of your smile, but sometimes your smile can be the source of your joy.” It is not surprising that our most revered images of God-inspired or God-illuminated persons are of them smiling. Such images inspire us to readily access the joyful peace they feel inwardly as that which we desire ourselves.

And I believe in being attentive or mindful to the present moment because we miss so much—and to find God in what is right in front of me.
In a speech at the United Nations in the 1980s, the poet and musician Pablo Casals he addressed the General Assembly, thinking of the children as the future of the new humanity:

The child must know that he himself is a miracle, that from the beginning of the world, never has there been another child just the same, and that in the whole future, there will never be another child like him. Every child is unique, from the beginning to the end of time. That way the child assumes a responsibility, as he confesses: it is true that I am a miracle. I am a miracle as the tree is a miracle. And being a miracle, could I do evil? No, because I am a miracle. I can say God or Nature, or God-nature. That’s not that important. What is important is that I am a miracle made by God and by nature. Could I kill someone? No. I cannot. And could another human being, who is also a miracle, kill me? I believe that what I am telling the children, could help bring about another way of thinking of the world and of life. The world of today is bad, yes it is a bad world. The world is bad because we do not talk to the children as I am talking to them now, in the way they need us to talk to them. Then the world will have no reason to be a bad world.

Leonardo Boff comments on Casals’ speech about children:

Great realism is revealed here: every reality, especially human reality, is unique and precious, but at the same time, we live in a conflicted world, contradictory and with terrifying aspects. In spite of all that, we must trust in the strength of the seed. The seed is filled with life. Every child that is born is a seed of a world that can be better. Because of that, it is worth having hope. A patient in a psychiatric hospital that I visited, printed with fire on a small board that he later gave me: “Every child who is born is a sign that God still believes in the human being.” It is not necessary to say anything more, because in these words lies the meaning of our hope as we face the evils and tragedies of this world.

During this third week of Advent, we ask the question of the Magi: “Where is he who has been born as king of the Jews?” (Mt. 2:2) If you are to experience the ever-present and ever-coming Christ, the one place you have to be is the one place you are usually not: NOW HERE! Everything important that happens to you happens right in the present moment. The reason we can trust the present moment is because of God taking flesh and God’s Spirit continued Indwelling. Christians carries the promise that the Word has become flesh, that God has entered into the human, and the human soul is the temple of God.

From the beginning of time billions of years ago, God had hope in this planet Earth, in life, and in humanity. God was born in a stable, a cave, laid in a manger as a sign that God still believes in us. We wait this third Sunday of Advent in darkness and embrace the quiet still moment of life with mindful joy and a smile.

We love by opening ourselves to the moment’s grace and trust in the uncertainties of life, and we realize in that moment of trust and openness the joy of being attentive to grace of the change—a change in our vision, in our lives where we behold in the moment a light shining above and in our hearts breaking the limits of darkness. God has the best chance of getting at us is in the momentary gaps, in the discontinuities, in the exceptions, in the surprises of the now.

The Zen Teacher tells us: “Pay attention to the moment.” Because in paying attention to the moment, the most sublime mystery of the universe takes place again and again: What this moment reveals, this now offers us is God’s grace–the birth of Jesus. Be awake in the moment and entertain the anticipation that God could be coming to me in this moment! Look around and see with faith. For this birth expresses a joyful awareness of the hope and joy for the world.

And the Christian mystic Meister Eckhart writes,

God is present, effective and powerful in all things. He is only generative, however, in the soul. For all creatures are a footprint of God, but the soul is formed like God, according to its nature. Whatever perfection is to enter the soul, be it divine, unique light or grace or happiness, all of it must come into the soul of a necessity through this birth of divine awareness and in no other way. Wait only for the birth of Christ within yourself, And you will discover all blessing and all consolation, all bliss, all being, and all truth.

The Grace of the Heart (Luke 10:25-37)

(As I surveyed scripture readings for this sermon on MCC United Church of Christ’s 42nd anniversary, I was reminded that I asked all who preached on our anniversaries to imitate the last lecture series popularized several years ago. I just made it the criteria: imagine and preach your last sermon—the sermon and message that you would want to pass on to folks with your last words.)
I would like to describe myself as a heart specialist: not in any medical definition, nor in one of the match making or dating services online. A heart specialist functions to bring healing to the world or to channel to others what has been abundantly and excessive given to me. I do actions for others. Why do I try to be compassionate and loving?

Each Sunday as I take communion, I practice a meditation from the Tibetan Buddhist tradition—called tonglen. It means “taking and sending” or “receiving and giving away.” I take on the burdens and sufferings of others, and I send out what graces I have received from God for others. These are the words you hear as I take the host—Christ’s body and God grace to us. “I take this communion and offer the grace for those who are hungry, for the homeless living on the streets, those suffering from war and oppression, and for the Earth which has been oppressed and ravaged by humanity. I offer this grace for healing.” I vary my words occasionally.

My tonglen communion practice is a meditation to connect myself and yourselves with suffering —our own and the suffering of the world that we livein. It is a heart practice that dissolves the tightness in our hearts and opens our hearts to the suffering around us. It unites the suffering and death of Christ whose words at the last supper form the core practice and in fact spiritual participation in his own death and resurrection. “This is my body broken and given for you. And this is cup of my blood, shed for you and for all for the forgiveness of sins. Do this in memory of me.” Whenever we remember the words and Christ’s inclusive hospitality at table, we are connected to the suffering and death of Christ and more.
My communion practice of tonglen connects the suffering and death of Christ with the suffering of people, other live, and the Earth. It is meant to awaken our compassion that we experience with God, who experiences the death of Christ and experiences the suffering of the world. It is the flow of God’s grace offered to us through Christ but that flow does not stop within our hearts or within us. What we receive we send to the suffering in the world. We never keep any gifting from God for our own but pass it on to those in greater need.

I chose Jesus’ parable of the Good Samaritan. It most exemplifies my opening words about tonglen communion practice. The story incarnates Jesus words in his sermon on the plain in Luke’s gospel: “Be compassionate as your Abba God is compassionate.” The context of the parable is the question to Jesus: “who is my neighbor?”

Jesus’ parable is an example that answers the question of neighbor. There ia man who travels from Jerusalem to Jericho but is mugged by robbers—who strip him, beat him, and leave him for dead. A priest is traveling the same direction sees the stripped body and deliberately goes out of his way to avoid the body. He does not even approach to see whether the man on the ground is still alive. Similarly, a Levite passes by the unconscious body as well; he disregards the body as well.

A Levite is a religious functionary who serves the priests in the Temple with their religious duties. They are like deacons, assisting the priests in their purifying hand washings and sacrificial role of killing and offering a portion of that animal to God.

Both priest and Levite are required by religious regulations to avoid occasions of impurity or defilement. Coming into contact with a dead corpse or nearly dead body would generate defilement so that they could not perform their religious duties in the Temple.

The third traveler–a Samaritan—despised by the Jews ethnically and religiously—sees the beaten body. He is moved to compassion, he treats the beaten man’s wounds with oil and bandages his wounds, places him on his own mount and brings him to an inn.

And the next day the Samaritan took out two denarii and the gave them to the innkeeper and said: “Take care of that man and whatever more you spend, when I return will give back to you.”

The details of the story have more depth when we look closely at the story. When I ask which character in the story I most identity with? I hope first for the Samaritan, but certainly not the priest and Levite, and perhaps most with the innkeeper. I will explain why momentarily.

The Australian poet, Henry Lawson, wrote a poem about the Samaritan. Listen to the third stanza:

He’s been a fool, perhaps, and would
Have prospered had he tried,
But he was one who never could
Pass by the other side.
An honest man whom men called soft,
While laughing in their sleeves —
No doubt in business ways he oft
Had fallen amongst thieves.

Lawson describes the Samaritan’s giving a foolish type exchange. From a business perspective, the exchange is not even an investment, it is a squandering of monies spent on someone already half dead and probably a sinner. How often is charitable giving is enclosed in businesss language of investment? Donations are given with strings attached. Or it is considered throwing the investment away unless it brings a return to the giver. Here Lawson characterizes the gifting of the wounded man by the Samaritan from a sense of compassionate care as an act of foolishness. From a business perspective, it is foolish giving with no return, squandering valuable capital on a poor investment.

On one level, the Samaritan in the parable is the Abba God of Jesus who attempts to compassionately love us. The Samaritan represents the God, who reaches out compassionately to the wounded man and relates to us as the good Samaritan. God compassionately offers extravagant life-giving care and hospitality to the wounded man left half dead.

When I reflect upon my experience of God’s love for myself, for you, and all life, I come up with: “extravagant hospitality” as the Father in the prodigal son parable rushing out to greet his returning son, “abundant love and unconditional love, and excessive compassion.” All these phases describe Hod’s giving to myself and yourselves.

What God gives us is excessive—more than we need or can use. We have life, the givenness of the world, friends, a community, companion animals, and more even if we think we have less.

God’s giving is not random—that is, a hit or miss display of love. It is prolific and wanton and directed at each of us. Its excessiveness generates our own giving. In the parable of the prodigal son, the son asks for inheritance and his father bestows upon himself. He goes away and squanders it on himself. The father gives the prodigal son his share of capital and property even knowing that his son will squander it. When he has lost everything, he returns home. And his father runs to meet him throwing his arms around him to welcome him. What the father has still is his son’s. The son not only learns about profound forgiveness and compassion from his father, but also learns that the joy of his father’s giving and giving again..

Excessive acts of kindness encourage more giving away. God’s giving always precedes us giving. God is love, and God’s love directed at us occurs before we are even aware of that divine gifting. But God’s giving always means that we who receive God’s excessive compassion and extravagant hospitality need to pass the gift on. When we pray in Lord’s prayer, “Give us this day our daily bread.” It is not merely prayer for daily bread for ourselves, for it is a prayer to receive bread to share with others. Whatever God gives to us, God gives for us to share and pass on.

Let’s go back to my identification with the innkeeper. The Samaritan gives the innkeeper a small subsidy or down payment in advance. The Samaritan entices the innkeeper to give more and provide generous care for the wounded man. The innkeeper gives again because he has received a gift. Is that not what God does with us? God call us to be innkeepers. God gives excessively and abundantly, and we as innkeepers are shaped by Good’s bountiful and over generous giving. In passing on God’s giving to us, we participate in God’s gifting by passing it onto others. God’s excessive acts of kindness are encouraged by a promise of repayment provides the opportunity to the innkeeper to pass the gift along to the wounded man.

Jesus holds up the Samaritan as a model of surprising generosity as Samaritan. It startles and shocks his Jewish audience. What Jesus intends to teach us is that God’s gifting creates a community of givers who empower others to give and in their cultivation of generosity and in gratitude to give again.

Stephen Webb, in his book, The Gifting God, writes:

Passing the gift along transforms the static and ambiguous obligation of gratitude into a joyous participation in the life of that gift. What we most give to others is to help them discover, develop, and deploy what they have to give, and sometimes this means that we must give up our own gifts, as did Jesus Christ, and learn how to receive.
For learning to receive God’s excessive gifts, God’s extravagant welcome and hospitality, God’s unconditional love is to learn not to hold onto the gifting but to pass the gifting away. We become channels of God’s gifting and, in turn, that gifting is passed on to others.
It stretches our imagination, for giving as God extravagantly gives to us becomes a goal and ideal for Christians. Religious sociologist Robert Wuthnow writes, “Helping others may not lead to a better society, but it allows us envision a better society.” We understand what Jesus’ parable presupposes: a new world where not only the barriers between us and them are dissolved, but that we realize that a stranger or even a supposed enemy can come to aid of one of us.
I believe with my whole heart and being in that dream of God for a better world shaped by God’s extravagant giving. Such actions in serving others, living and fighting for justice of people, other life, and the Earth

“Everything Belongs to God..” (Matthew 22:15-22)

I am like everyone else I hate paying taxes for a number of reasons but I am realist that many of our services, that I expect, would be curtailed or non-existence. Taxes are a necessary part of living in the US. I do dislike the fact that taxes are unfair, especially on the poor and the middle class, when the very wealthy can pay at a lesser tax rate than many of us. The billionaire Warren Buffet has called attention to the fact his secretary pays a higher rate of taxes than he does as a billionaire because of the tax loopholes and deductions that are available to him but not to his secretary. I dislike how corporations shift monies overseas to pay reduced taxes and pay rates less than any of us.

Today’s gospel appears to be about taxes, but I want to suggest that the issue is more than taxes. The first clue is that the Pharisees joined the Herodians to entrap Jesus. You see the Pharisees and the Herodians are enemies, they are political parties frequently in conflict over their goals. In this case, they unite against Jesus. They become convenient friends to go after Jesus.
The Herodians developed their power from the Roman occupation. They were named after Herod the Great—the king who tried to kill Jesus in Bethlehem. His son Herod Antipater killed John the Baptist. Herod made life difficult for Jesus, and we can safely assume that Jesus was itinerant, constantly moving around Galilee and in and out Galilee, escaping the troops of Herod. They were the landed gentry who practiced their Jewish religion with explicit allegiance to Rome. They were Hellenized Jews who practiced the religious cult to the Emperor. The Roman Empire kept them in power as they oppressed Galilean peasants.
The Pharisees represented the purity party that supported the Temple and chief priests. They built a fence around the Torah regulations with a series of oral traditions to keep as pure as the Temple priests. Yet the Pharisees collected the Temple tithes and reinforced a boycott of those who did not pay there Temple dues. Out of necessity, they deferred to Roman authority because the Temple cooperated with the Romans.

The Herodians represented the interests of the Roman Empire and its system of control while the Pharisees represented the Temple interests. The Herodians felt Judaism’s future belonged to Rome and the Herods installed as rulers by Rome. They supported the Roman system of taxation that was burdensome and kept the Jewish peasants poorer. The Herodians became money launderers for the Roman tribute, and they profited from the money exchange of Jewish coinage into Roman coinage.

The Herodians stood by Herod Antipas in Galilee. Herod had killed John the Baptist, and here was another popular charismatic prophet causing trouble. In fact, people from the circle of Herod Antipas found their way to this charismatic prophet. Joanna, the wife of an administration official in Herod’s court, became a disciple of Jesus.

The Romans levied a grain tax, taxes on all produce, sales taxes, occupational taxes on certain trades and guilds, custom taxes, temple taxes, transit taxes. These revenues from conquered peoples supported Roma and its citizens. The Pharisees represented the alternative religious tax system that took 10% of all that the peasants produced plus the requirements for sacrifices for forgiveness, annual feasts and festivals in Jerusalem. 95% of the Jews who lived in Palestine suffered from the burdensome taxes.

These two groups come together in their opposition to Jesus. Jesus disturbs the religious and political powers with his message of God’s reign. We have seen where religious and political groups align themselves together against an opponent. In 2008, the Mormons, the Catholics, and the Evangelicals came to support Prop 8 because of their opposition to same-sex marriage while despising each other.

They intend to ensnare Jesus on the question of taxes. Will he deny the taxation system of the Roman Empire or the Temple? In the coinage collected by Roman officials and their proxies, they collected denarri with the image of the Emperor Tiberius, son of the divine Augustus Caesar. The Pharisees would objected to the denarii or foreign currency. For the Temple taxes and offering had to be exchanged for coins without the image of Caesar or acknowledging any national god outside of the Jewish God. The Jewish God was the only God. The Pharisees advanced the view that any payment to the emperor with denarii coins was idolatry. The Pharisees rejected foreign currency because it violated the first commandment against graven images. In Judea, the Temple authorities minted coins in Hebrew creating an alternative religious currency. Jewish coinage or coinage without any image of Caesar or god was acceptable.
Payment of Roman taxes meant paying tribute to Rome and its divine ruler and gods. The Pharisees did not want to accommodate with the Greco-Roman culture nor with paying tribute. But they were forced since ending the tribute would have brought dire consequences of the Roman military, further enslavements and punishments.

So the question posed to Jesus by the Herodians and Pharisees: “Teacher, we know you are sincere, and teach the way of God in accordance with truth, and show deference to no one, for you do not regard people with partiality. Tell us what you think. Is it lawful to pay taxes to the emperor or not?”

When Jesus asked for the coin, he realized his challengers asked him to make a choice between two taxation systems, fraught with political consequences. Did he publicly side with the Herodians or the Pharisees? Or, did Jesus side with the accommodating Herodians who saw relations with Rome as the future? If he agreed with the Pharisees, the Herodians could charge him with rebellion against Rome. If Jesus agreed with the Herodians, the Pharisees could charge him with idolatry. And this would end the week-long challenges of Jesus in Jerusalem and discredit him in the eyes of the people.

Jesus asked for a coin. When Jesus asked for the image and the title on the coin, he made the Pharisees and the Herodians face up to the choice they gave him. Rome or the Temple? Jesus cleverly sidetracked the political trap.

Jesus renders his verdict as they produce a coin. He says to them, “whose head is this and whose title is this?” They concede, “The emperor’s.” Then Jesus says, “Give therefore to the emperor the things that are the emperor’s, and to God the things that are God’s.” When two options are presented in Aramaic language, it is always the second that holds importance. In this case, he says pay the taxes to Caesar but recognize that ultimately the greater allegiance belongs to God. Jesus probably remembered the prayer in the Psalm:
The earth belongs to the Lord, and all that is in it,
The world and those who live in it.

Jesus prohibits unquestioning loyalty to Rome, and a few days later in his demonstration in the Temple, in his prophetic action of overturning the table of the money-changers, he pronounces his verdict, “My father’s house has become a den of thieves.”

Loyalty and allegiance to the Roman Empire or to the Jewish Temple are secondary to the reign of God. Unquestioning loyalty to the state or to the church are dangerous at any time. Jesus message about God’s reign takes precedence over all claims. The guards at the Nazi concentration camps considered themselves loyal Germans and good Christians. And look at the atrocities they did in crucifying Christ in the concentration camps

(Youtube Clip from Bonhoeffer: Agent of Grace, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GtEzV9jTpvI

Dietrich Bonhoeffer and his writings are studied in many mainline seminaries and universities. In the early 1930s, he studied at Union Theological Seminary in New York City with the famous theologian Reinhold Niebuhr, a member of of one of the earlier churches that formed into the United Church of Christ in 1957, and Bonhoeffer participated in the Abyssinian American Baptist Church in Harlem and enjoyed African-American Spirituals. He was on collision course with the Nazi politics of his native Germany. He joined the resistance. Next week after service we watch the movie—Bonhoeffer: Agent of Grace. But today I want to show you a clip from the movie when the Gestapo come into church, informing Bonhoeffer that he can no longer teach, preach, or lead worship. The Gestapo intimate the congregation to profess the Nuremberg Confession:

The pastor/theologian Dietrich Bonhoeffer wrote,

Let’s not delude ourselves that if we take the loyalty oath to Hitler it means they’ll let us worship in peace. The Nuremberg laws are an attack on Christianity itself. Adolf Hitler demands nothing less than total commitment. He’s the elected chancellor, yes. But more than that, he considers himself de Fuhrer, and as “the leader,” he craves to be the conscience of every living German. But his claim upon us is a claim that a Christian can only accept from Christ Himself.

There are times that our conscience informed by the Gospel of Christ and our God may lead us to realize that there is a higher allegiance than Caesar or Hitler or corporate greed. I tried to think of one, and my thought is on the Tar Sands pipeline from Canada. Should it be approved, thousands, if not tens of thousands of people who love and care for the Earth, will stand and obstruct the construction of the pipeline which will cross the largest aquifer in the heartland of the US. A major spill could effect the water supplies of millions of Americans and American farming. It is folly to construct this for greed for fossil fuel. I will stand with Sierra Club and peoples of faith in civil disobedience to such a construction project. It will harm the Earth and life. Here is a more contemporary example of rendering to God.

The Challenge of Evil: Matthew 21:33-46

This parable originates with Jesus and against the backdrop of conflict with the Jewish leadership of the Temple. It was perhaps the last week of Jesus’ life. This is called the parable of the “murderous tenants.” The vineyard is a typical image for Israel with God as the absentee landlord. The servant who are sent to collect the revenue or portion of the produce of the vineyard at harvest time are the prophets. One is beaten, another killed, and the third stoned. The landlord sends his own son, “They will respect him.” But they seize him, threw him out of the vineyard, and killed him for his inheritance.

Jesus addresses a crowd in Jerusalem, asking them: “Now when the owner of the vineyard comes, what will he do to those tenants?” The crowd answers, “He will put those wretches to a miserable death, and lease the vineyard to other tenants who will give him the produce at harvest time.”

Two things stand out immediately in this parable. The first is the courage of Jesus telling this parable about his fate and expected death in Jerusalem the week before his crucifixion. How many of could tell a story about our impending murder and death? The second is that the Pharisees and the priestly leadership of the Temple hear this parable directed at themselves.

In the gospel today, the temple leadership realizes that Jesus’ parable undermines question their leadership abilities over the vineyard. There has been a series of confrontations and oral conflicts this last week in Jerusalem. They may have been seething with anger but the crowds temper their anger public display of anger. The crowd viewed Jesus as a prophet.

But what does Jesus mean telling such a gloomy and prophetic parable? This is certainly not God’s reign with the tenants killing the vineyard owner’s son. Is the reign of God with God coming end wreaking vengeance upon the murderers of his son?

If we leave at the end of the parable, we might make some sense of the story as the opposite of God’s kin-dom. This is not God’s kin-dom, this is the way of the Roman Empire and the empires of the world. These are the actions of religious folks in Jesus’ time and in our time.

For his audience, there is hope that the temple leadership will get their due for their greed, oppression of the poor, and desire for power. There is a glee in their fate and punishment. But the landlord portrayed is not the God of Jesus and his ministry. It is a vengeful God taught by the temple leadership. This is how the world works and how God deals with such a world from traditional religion. God punishes the wicked, even vengefully.

But Jesus throws a curb into his story with the addition: He says, “Have you never read in the scriptures: “The stone that the builders rejected has become the cornerstone; this was the Lord’s doing, and it is amazing in our eyes?” Jesus goes on: Therefore I will tell you, the kin-dom of God will be taken away from you and given to a people who produces fruits of the kin-dom.” He disturbs his own story with how God will genuinely act to overcome the evil of the murderous action of the tenants. God will undermine the vision of the world that promotes violence and killing as the only solution.

Jesus quotes a verse from Psalm 118:22-23 that changes the parable. Jesus affirms God often changes the circumstances even when they are tragic and horrific. He affirms that even his own death is the ultimate violation warranting the vengeance of death. God, however, works differently from human empires and religious institutions. God will restore the stone that is foundational for the kin-dom and rejected by the tenants. That is how God works with surprises and unexpected ways. There will be a new people who will bring the reign of God, and it will neither be the Romans nor the coopted Temple leadership. It will be people of the resurrected one who trust in God with their hearts even when all odds are against them.

The core affirmation of Jesus is that God’s resurrection of himself and resurrection in general tells us much about the gracious God of the universe and how God deals with evil and tragedy in life.

Jesus recognizes that there is a lethal price to pay in Jerusalem for the week of conflicts and confrontations with the religious authorities. He will pay dearly with his life, crucified to a cross by the Romans.

I want to turn your attention to the not too distant past when several folks who bore witness to Christ and God’s kin-dom and care for the poor against the military rulers, the rich families that supported the oppressed the poor and hungry, and the church bishops who refused to speak out. Archbishop Oscar Romero, a moderate bishop in San Salvador, who cared about his people spoke up against the military violence and injustice against the people. In the movie, Romero, he is a poor village, and his cassock is torn by the military officer, and the Archbishop starts to preside at a mass on the spot. He lives the gospel of Christ in the midst of persecution.

Here are his words:

It is very easy to be servants of the word without disturbing the world: a very spiritualized word, a word without any commitment to history, a word that can sound in any part of the world because it belongs to no part of the world. A word like that creates no problems, starts no conflicts. What starts conflicts and persecutions, what marks the genuine Church, is the word that, burning like the word of the prophets, proclaims and accuses; proclaims to the people God’s wonders to be believed and venerated, and accuses of sin those who oppose God’s reign.

Romero mirrors the ministry of Jesus God’s Christ in the last week before his death in Jerusalem. He– like prophets sent to the tenants– was murdered at the altar by a military assassin while celebrating mass. He knew in his heart that in following Christ he would be killed. Even today the Catholic bishops of El Salvador have blocked the investigation into the death of Romero because of the Catholic Church’s complicity in his death. The tenants of the vineyard are still alive.

I find myself in admiration and awe of Jesus for telling this parable about himself and his placing his trust and heart in Abba God. It raises a question the title of a book written by the Jewish rabbi Harold Kushner—When Bad Things Happen to Good People. He wrote the book because his three year old son was diagnosed with a degenerative disease and would live only into his early teens. He writes as heart-broken parent and rabbi. There are no easy solution to the doubts, fears, and questions when tragedy or something terrible happens. This is a question that impacts all of us who have been challenged by various cancers, health challenges, tragedies, and harm perpetrated against us.

According to John chapter 9, Jesus was unable to answer a question why a man was born blind. He rejected the Temple authorities and Pharisee’s explanation that the man was born blind because of his sin or the sins of his parents. Jesus refused to accept the explanation. Evil and tragedy may strike you and spare your neighbor or person who is just the nastiest person imaginable. This mystery has bewildered the understanding of human beings from the very beginning of history. There is no easy answer, Jesus felt that on the cross when he cried, “My God, my God, why have you forsaken me!”

Let me push this problem to another example of horrific proportions.

Another Jewish author, Elie Wiesel, who authored the book The Trial of God, explores this issue in massive death. It takes place while he was imprisoned in Auschwitz. A group of rabbis in the concentration camp placed God on trial during the worst possible nightmare of death and horror they could imagine—the extermination of Jews and other peoples by the Nazis.

If you have ever gone through a Holocaust Museum, you will understood part of the magnitude of evil and horror. I went through the Holocaust Museum in Washing D.C. I was speaking at Georgetown University on gay theology, and the hos that I was staying with arranged for me to go through a VIP tour of the Museum. You can choose a real live person to follow through the concentration camp. I chose a gay man who was interred and died the gas chambers in Auschwitz. My mistake was going through the experience alone. I witnessed the cattle car that housed and shipped a hundred people to the camp. I saw a real gas chamber, the art of the children murdered in the chambers, and the smelled the decaying shoes left over and brought from the camp. At the end of tour you end up a quiet space to feel the intense emotions evoked by the experience. There were several people in the room in tears, including myself.

Going back to Wiesel, several rabbis place God on trial for God’s silence about the experience at Auschwitz. The issue is the questioning of God by Job on the justice of God. Is God apathetic because does God not care or is God powerless to save us?

In this case, the trial is how can the rabbis understand God to be just and good in light of the innocent suffering and massive death around themselves? If is truly God, why does God limit God’s power in this situation of horror and the many horrific events in history. At the end of the trial, the rabbis find God guilty of silence, but they take some hoarded bread crumbs to celebrate the Friday Sabbath service. They are faithful to observe the Sabbath and placed their faith in God despite the guilty verdict.

Elie Wiesel often retells the story about two Holocaust survivors, one a rabbi, who meet after liberation of the camps by the Allies. The survivor asks the rabbi how he can still believe in God after all he witnessed and experienced in the concentration camp. The rabbi responds by asking how, after all their experiences of the horror and death that has happened, can he not believe in God.

The question of evil and its meaning when it strikes—such as diagnosis of cancer or a terminal illness or the horrors of death of AIDS in the early stages of the pandemic—remain unanswerable. We can look to the faithfulness of the rabbis who attested that God may be silent but God was with them in their suffering and impending death.

Or we as Christians can look to Jesus. He answers, “The stone that the builders rejected has become the cornerstone.” He points to his trust he has in Abba God and the resurrection. God may allow his creatures to do evil actions and crimes, but God experiences our suffering, knows what it means to abandoned and betrayed, arrested, flogged, scorned, the pain of crucifixion, and the last and painful breath of Jesus as he dies. We may not have the answers when bad things and evil strike us, but we know that God is with us each step with us and God will raise us to life with God’s self.

Sermon for Francis of Assisi “Embracing all Creation” by James Stuart

James Stuart is a Druid/Wiccan priest and dear friend of our church. He preached with husband Michael on St. Francis of Assisi Sunday. Enjoy the message..

A friend shared an interesting story on facebook just last Sunday. It chronicled what happened when wolves were intentionally introduced back into Yellowstone National Park in 1995. The Deer and Wapiti population had exploded in the park due to a human created lack of natural predators and were completely disrupting the ecosystem. Some areas had been grazed and browsed down to a near desert like status. When the wolves re-entered the ecosystem, they killed and ate a few deer, culling the herd. But the changes didn’t stop there.

The deer stopped frequenting open areas where they were easier prey, in particular the open over-grazed valleys. These areas almost immediately began to sprout new growth, inviting back birds, squirrels, insects, and reptiles. Within a few years, barren plains had become meadows and were turning into forests. Existing trees previously kept stunted by the browsing deer, shot up an astounding five times their height in just a few years. These trees then became an attraction for beavers. The dams built by the beavers created a welcoming environment for returning fish, amphibians, ducks and otters.

The wolves also killed and displaced some of the oversized coyote population, with the result that rabbits, mice, and other small rodents began to multiply again. This then, attracted their natural predators: foxes, weasels, badgers, hawks and bald eagles. Most remarkably of all, the rivers themselves, because of less erosion, and the dams of the beavers, became more stable in their courses, with less flooding or loss of topsoil to the surrounding areas. The entire ecosystem benefited. This phenomenon, where a species at the very top of the food chain has a dramatic impact upon its entire environment and beyond, is referred to as a “trophic cascade.”

This story serves to underscore the importance and value of every species in the rich tapestry of creation. Francis of Assisi, whose feast day is today, understood a little of this, and was condemned for it by many of his fellow churchmen. He lived in an era when all of creation was considered by most, to be placed by God, at man’s disposal to do with what he liked, even unto destruction. Fortunately, far fewer people still believe this today. Unfortunately, some still do.

As people of faith, we are watched and judged, and followed by others. We are expected not only to speak out upon moral issues, and to take moral action, but also, we are judged by what form that action takes. We are not political leaders, who are often forgiven for committing crimes in the name of justice, waging war in the name of peace. We are not allowed such leniency, not by the public, not by our consciences, not by the Divine. Because we claim to answer to a higher power, we are held to a higher standard.

Francis too, felt that he had to speak out about what he felt was right. He advocated and took a vow of poverty, when many in the church had grown rich and fat on the contributions of the poor. These corrupt churchmen found his selflessness, and respect for all beings, human and non-human threatening. When he appealed to the Vatican to create his own order, the Franciscan, some, particularly amongst the wealthy and powerful Dominican Order tried to stop him by accusing him of an “unnatural love of animals.” The implication was, not that he understood and loved all of Nature, as God’s wonderful gift of Creation to be cherished, but that he engaged in bestiality, and was therefore the worst of sinners, perhaps even a heretic. Because he questioned and upset the established quo, he was being attacked personally.

Today, is no different. There are those who refer to those of us who speak out with legitimate concerns about the health of our planet, as “eco-terrorists” or “environmental fascists.” Nonetheless, we will continue to speak out. We cannot do otherwise.

But speaking out is not enough. We must act. Like the wolves of Yellowstone, we are at the top of the food chain. What we do as a species, even as individuals, most often has a far more dramatic and far-reaching effect upon our environment than we could ever imagine at the time. This has certainly been true of the thing which we have done with resulting ill effect, but it can also be for the better as well. Our government’s visionary, conscious and deliberate reintroduction of the wolves to Yellowstone is an excellent and awe-inspiring example. We must not lose sight of the fact, that as the primary source of change upon this planet, we have the ability to be the primary source of improvement and renewal. We can be responsible for our own trophic cascade.

In many religions, perhaps most, humanity is viewed as being the link between Creator or Creatrix and Creation itself. We have dared to believe, that though we are not quite divine, we are also somehow not quite completely a part of Creation. Indeed, it is that notion of being somehow above Creation, which has got us into this environmental mess in the first place. But, we are a part of Creation. We are not just its recipients, not just its custodians; we are part and parcel of it. And it is part and parcel of us. We are the cognitive link between the Divine which creates and that which has been created. We understand, or at least, flatter ourselves that we understand, some small part of the will of God. That notion, also, has frequently got us into much trouble in the past, but can just as well, with perseverance and some sacrifice, can also be our salvation.

In the beginning of Genesis is the Word, the Logos, also called the Divine Wisdom, the Hagia Sophia. This is the spark of all Creation, elsewhere referred to as the Holy Spirit. This is the spark which we carry within ourselves. This is the spark which we must use to ignite a wildfire of understanding, compassion, empathy, peace and harmony, especially in these troubling times, for all people, of all religions, for all beings, for all of Creation. We are all children of God. We must never forget that. If we are ever to be worthy of the unique position which we hold in this planet, we must rise to this challenge. We have very nearly been the death of Creation. We must now seek and find the Divine Nature placed by God within ourselves and become the Resurrection.

In order for you to better understand my own perspective, I will give a couple of examples from our Druid liturgy. In each of our rituals, we honor the Divine, as we see it, in all its varied forms, and we honor our Ancestors, all of those who have come before us, regardless of race, or religion.

But also, we honor what we call in Gaelic the Sprideanna na Talaimh, the Spirits of the Land, “Creatures of Fur, Fin and Feather, of Bark, Leaf and Twig, of Stone, Rock and Crystal, Creatures both Seen and Unseen.” The belief held here, is that we are all one family, and that the Spark of Creation, which we call the Awen, and which you know as the Holy Spirit exists in everything, whether it appears alive or visible to us or not. The Awen is the symbol which I wear around my neck, three tongues of flame descending from the Heavens to inspire humanity, like the Holy Spirit of the Pentecost.

Also, amongst our Sacred Hallows, we bless and sanctify a tree. It is not the specific tree which is important. We do not worship it, contrary to what some believe. It is merely symbolic of a concept, a great World Tree, which exists only in Spirit, our Spirit, the Holy Spirit. Its roots are said to grow deep into the nether realms where the dead sleep, waiting to be awakened. Its branches are said to reach high into the Heavens, beyond the Gods whom we claim to know, to touch the very Face and Breath of the Unfathomable One Who has created us all. Its trunk and branches stretch out to support and touch every being on Earth, every part of Creation. You can see why I associate it with the Holy Spirit. It is with this belief and understanding that we say in our liturgy, “Crann Naomh, fas isteeach muidsan. Sacred Tree, grow within us.”

We are asking that the Holy Spirit which connects all of Creation to God, continue to thrive and grow within ourselves, that we might become not just worthy of Divine salvation and blessing, but its very instrument. To some, this may sound a bit vain on the part of imperfect beings such as ourselves. But with all humility, I believe that it is necessary, now more than ever, and I believe that Saint Francis of Assisi would wholeheartedly agree. With that in mind I offer you this final wish and blessing: may the Sacred Tree grow within each and all of you.